A seer’s arrest: the Hindu response
A seer’s arrest: the Hindu response
The arrest of the Sankaracharya has brought to the fore contradictions inherent in the Hindu faith. But it will be a sad day if the Hindu turns to zealotry, argues TARUN VIJAY, an RSS ideologue, from what is essentially a Hindu point of view
No Hindu will protest if Sankaracharya is hanged after conviction. Rather we would demand a double noose for him, one for the crime and the other for desecrating the high office of spiritualism.
But suppose he is let off and nothing is proved against him? He would have been a dead man even then. Nothing can now restore the great glory and position of the Kanchi Math built so carefully over the past 2,500 years. The state cannot say it is not concerned with this because it affects the majority of its citizens, who are bewildered by the turn of events.
This couldn’t have happened at a worse time. The entire Hindu pariwar is a picture of disarray and infighting. Bruised and busy calling each other names, those who stood for Hindus in politics are teased and suffer the sarcasm of others for their docility. Perhaps those taunting them feel unless there is a protest killing like Theo van Gogh’s in Amsterdam, a protest is not genuine.
So to be heard and respected, Hindus ought to have been issuing death threats, to all those involved in the arrest of a seer who had emerged as a global icon of Hindu Dharma fighting untouchability, training Harijan pujaris and building charitable hospitals and schools of repute, besides helping solve matters of faith entangled in political imbroglios. Sorry, we didn’t do that.
Definitely those working to destabilise Hindus and aiming to have a full “harvest” of their weaker sections would have felt perturbed. The Kanchi Shankarachraya represented a phenomenon of resurgence and self-confidence occurring after centuries of subjugation and colonial rule over Hindus. True Hindus have not come out on the streets and burnt public property in protest, but it will be a travesty of truth to say they are not pained or anguished.
There is a reason for looking unconcerned, if the only mark of concern is a public display of anarchy. In the first place, the powerful media blitzkrieg, which in this case completely presented the prosecution’s side as the authentic version, (though prosecution cases against terrorists are still treated with concerns for human rights and are always tinged with doubt), made commoners, already fed on the secular notions that these sadhus are mostly good for nothing corrupt idlers, too stunned to react.
For all practical purposes a man called Sankaracharya Jayendra Saraswati is as dead as a log, even before a single charge has been framed, much less proved. Murder, financial frauds, womanising, child abuse… what other charges do you need to decimate a person?
The way some magazines and organisations are making fun of Hindus on this episode is not surprising. They know, as one Pakistani scholar told me recently in Lahore, we Hindus can only live in this country as facilitators to non-Hindu powers or as their court jesters like Birbal. Even if we rule, the Hindu ruling elite class can survive by distancing itself from the mainstream Hindu concerns and acting in line with the colonial invaders securing power and position only through a compromising attitude known as Jodhabai phenomenon.
Looking down at everything Hindu, their language, their rituals, their attire – dhoti chotiwale – was considered natural, and special privileges to non-Hindu religious brethren came as unbiased actions of the state. Shivaji and Ranjit Singh are exceptions. The rest of our history is replete with such examples.
Nothing has changed. Hindus must learn to live in their shells, accept the attire and the protocol regime of the colonialists, should not exert their identity and keep on worshipping for their personal welfare. Hence we must not complain if a Shahabuddin or a Taslimuddin is treated with utmost respect and care, none of two dozen non-bailable warrants is executed on Shahi Imam and hawala and income tax evasion cases against a Hurriyat leader are forgotten.
Nor should we feel discriminated against if Hindu temples alone are taken under control by the government with atheists in charge. You just can’t expect this state power to take over Haji Ali or St. Xaviers on the pretext of better management or run Khwaja Nizamuddin Chishti’s Dargah to stop financial irregularities. Similarly to subsidise Haj is correct, while stiff posture on a Hindu yatra helps a Hindu politician whether he is in a “Hindu nationalist” BJP or Congress.
To be seen and working as a Hindu helps neither a politician nor a media person. But to emphasise your non-Hindu identity and yet be included in a secular mainstream is an “in” thing and helps strengthen your position in power and also to reinforce objective and politically correct credentials in whatever field you work. That’s the reason even a suave and highly revered saint Sree Sree Ravishankar had to complain that we are in denial and Hindus feel ashamed to emphasise their identity.
There have been numerous examples of cases of moral turpitude and financial bungling against Christian priests and Muslim clergy in Kerala, Meghalaya and Ajmer but none of them got pursued or was taken up by the national media. When a chief minister attacks an editor, every body would say, even before an investigation is organised, that she is wrong. But when the same person attacks a seer, faithful presentation of the state’s prosecution is considered the correct dharma!
The irony is that there is a total disconnect between the personal religious behaviour of a Hindu and his public posture. In private his devotion is limited to believing in the miraculous powers of sadhus, havans, yajnas and rings, but he would shy away from doing anything for the faith in public. He would publicly demonstrate his respect for a religious godman to win over some votes of the gullible devout and not genuinely as a devotee. He would not feel that it’s his duty to see the prestige of a Hindu institution is saved even while the guilty is punished. Hindu scriptures have yet to have a mass appeal, as people do not understand the basic tenets of Hinduism. It has been, unfortunately reduced to rituals and petty “contracts” with Bhagwan.
Today the best a Hindu does is to ask his Bhagwan or a swami to help him get a job, a foreign posting or a ministership and in turn a hefty amount would be offered at the master’s lotus feet. That’s it. Its purely a secular arrangement of facilities between a Hindu and his ‘deity’, with no attention to conduct in life as propagated by Gita and stressed by our reformers such as Vivekananda, Dayananda, Buddha and Nanak.
Dharma connected with Rashtra, as Sri Aurobindo envisioned in his Bhawani Bharati, presenting the concept of nation as a living entity of Durga, is real Hinduism, not the petty rituals.
The prevailing perception is that our ochre robed swamis too have done little and have not shown a real concern for the Dharma living as luxuriously as possible with our pilgrim centres and temples presenting a sorry state of affairs. This picture, true to some extent, is presented larger than the reality and thus has also contributed to spread a sense of dejection and cynicism amongst commoners for religious preachers. The irony is that the noble works of most of the ochre robed swamis never get their due in the media.
Many are engaged in activities like hospitals, schools, mobile dispensaries and so on. The Kanchi seer, Swaminarayan, Amritanandmayi and Swadhyaya Pariwar are just a few names and if there are wrong deeds they are opposed and exposed without any mercy by Hindus themselves, while other religious faithfuls try to hide it under the cover of secularism.
A swami like Sai Baba has contributed most to establish the technical and medical colleges and provided drinking water facility to Ananthpur district. Similarly Mata Amritanandmayi is hailed as a reformist Hindu seer, building super speciality hospitals and educational institutions. Ramakrishna Mission revolutionised the whole concept of a sanyasi through the principle of “Jiber Shewa Shiver Shewa”, that is, to serve humanity is to serve God.
It will be a sad day if driven to the wall Hindus start organising themselves on the lines of a church or an Islamic ummah to be heard and recognised. That would be the Islamisation process, as brutal and proselytising in its character as it could be.
In any event, and to return to the case of the Sankaracharya, Hindus will feel both shame and anger in either situation – the seer’s conviction or release – and this could erupt at a time no one can predict. Hindus should adopt a policy of wait and watch and hope that this case is transferred out of Tamil Nadu, as the state has become a den of revenge and hate.
If the courts hold he is guilty, there ought to be no complaints. If he is innocent, let the law say so and till then let him pass through the most excruciatingly grilling time. We have passed through more traumatic times. On the contrary the shock may bring some change in our lethargic attitudes towards dharma and its exponents.
Mercifully no power is a permanent one, even Saddam had to quit. But the State, especially one that prides itself on its secularism, ought to have used more caution and discretion.
(The author is Editor, Panchjanya, the RSS news magazine.)
The arrest of the Sankaracharya has brought to the fore contradictions inherent in the Hindu faith. But it will be a sad day if the Hindu turns to zealotry, argues TARUN VIJAY, an RSS ideologue, from what is essentially a Hindu point of view
No Hindu will protest if Sankaracharya is hanged after conviction. Rather we would demand a double noose for him, one for the crime and the other for desecrating the high office of spiritualism.
But suppose he is let off and nothing is proved against him? He would have been a dead man even then. Nothing can now restore the great glory and position of the Kanchi Math built so carefully over the past 2,500 years. The state cannot say it is not concerned with this because it affects the majority of its citizens, who are bewildered by the turn of events.
This couldn’t have happened at a worse time. The entire Hindu pariwar is a picture of disarray and infighting. Bruised and busy calling each other names, those who stood for Hindus in politics are teased and suffer the sarcasm of others for their docility. Perhaps those taunting them feel unless there is a protest killing like Theo van Gogh’s in Amsterdam, a protest is not genuine.
So to be heard and respected, Hindus ought to have been issuing death threats, to all those involved in the arrest of a seer who had emerged as a global icon of Hindu Dharma fighting untouchability, training Harijan pujaris and building charitable hospitals and schools of repute, besides helping solve matters of faith entangled in political imbroglios. Sorry, we didn’t do that.
Definitely those working to destabilise Hindus and aiming to have a full “harvest” of their weaker sections would have felt perturbed. The Kanchi Shankarachraya represented a phenomenon of resurgence and self-confidence occurring after centuries of subjugation and colonial rule over Hindus. True Hindus have not come out on the streets and burnt public property in protest, but it will be a travesty of truth to say they are not pained or anguished.
There is a reason for looking unconcerned, if the only mark of concern is a public display of anarchy. In the first place, the powerful media blitzkrieg, which in this case completely presented the prosecution’s side as the authentic version, (though prosecution cases against terrorists are still treated with concerns for human rights and are always tinged with doubt), made commoners, already fed on the secular notions that these sadhus are mostly good for nothing corrupt idlers, too stunned to react.
For all practical purposes a man called Sankaracharya Jayendra Saraswati is as dead as a log, even before a single charge has been framed, much less proved. Murder, financial frauds, womanising, child abuse… what other charges do you need to decimate a person?
The way some magazines and organisations are making fun of Hindus on this episode is not surprising. They know, as one Pakistani scholar told me recently in Lahore, we Hindus can only live in this country as facilitators to non-Hindu powers or as their court jesters like Birbal. Even if we rule, the Hindu ruling elite class can survive by distancing itself from the mainstream Hindu concerns and acting in line with the colonial invaders securing power and position only through a compromising attitude known as Jodhabai phenomenon.
Looking down at everything Hindu, their language, their rituals, their attire – dhoti chotiwale – was considered natural, and special privileges to non-Hindu religious brethren came as unbiased actions of the state. Shivaji and Ranjit Singh are exceptions. The rest of our history is replete with such examples.
Nothing has changed. Hindus must learn to live in their shells, accept the attire and the protocol regime of the colonialists, should not exert their identity and keep on worshipping for their personal welfare. Hence we must not complain if a Shahabuddin or a Taslimuddin is treated with utmost respect and care, none of two dozen non-bailable warrants is executed on Shahi Imam and hawala and income tax evasion cases against a Hurriyat leader are forgotten.
Nor should we feel discriminated against if Hindu temples alone are taken under control by the government with atheists in charge. You just can’t expect this state power to take over Haji Ali or St. Xaviers on the pretext of better management or run Khwaja Nizamuddin Chishti’s Dargah to stop financial irregularities. Similarly to subsidise Haj is correct, while stiff posture on a Hindu yatra helps a Hindu politician whether he is in a “Hindu nationalist” BJP or Congress.
To be seen and working as a Hindu helps neither a politician nor a media person. But to emphasise your non-Hindu identity and yet be included in a secular mainstream is an “in” thing and helps strengthen your position in power and also to reinforce objective and politically correct credentials in whatever field you work. That’s the reason even a suave and highly revered saint Sree Sree Ravishankar had to complain that we are in denial and Hindus feel ashamed to emphasise their identity.
There have been numerous examples of cases of moral turpitude and financial bungling against Christian priests and Muslim clergy in Kerala, Meghalaya and Ajmer but none of them got pursued or was taken up by the national media. When a chief minister attacks an editor, every body would say, even before an investigation is organised, that she is wrong. But when the same person attacks a seer, faithful presentation of the state’s prosecution is considered the correct dharma!
The irony is that there is a total disconnect between the personal religious behaviour of a Hindu and his public posture. In private his devotion is limited to believing in the miraculous powers of sadhus, havans, yajnas and rings, but he would shy away from doing anything for the faith in public. He would publicly demonstrate his respect for a religious godman to win over some votes of the gullible devout and not genuinely as a devotee. He would not feel that it’s his duty to see the prestige of a Hindu institution is saved even while the guilty is punished. Hindu scriptures have yet to have a mass appeal, as people do not understand the basic tenets of Hinduism. It has been, unfortunately reduced to rituals and petty “contracts” with Bhagwan.
Today the best a Hindu does is to ask his Bhagwan or a swami to help him get a job, a foreign posting or a ministership and in turn a hefty amount would be offered at the master’s lotus feet. That’s it. Its purely a secular arrangement of facilities between a Hindu and his ‘deity’, with no attention to conduct in life as propagated by Gita and stressed by our reformers such as Vivekananda, Dayananda, Buddha and Nanak.
Dharma connected with Rashtra, as Sri Aurobindo envisioned in his Bhawani Bharati, presenting the concept of nation as a living entity of Durga, is real Hinduism, not the petty rituals.
The prevailing perception is that our ochre robed swamis too have done little and have not shown a real concern for the Dharma living as luxuriously as possible with our pilgrim centres and temples presenting a sorry state of affairs. This picture, true to some extent, is presented larger than the reality and thus has also contributed to spread a sense of dejection and cynicism amongst commoners for religious preachers. The irony is that the noble works of most of the ochre robed swamis never get their due in the media.
Many are engaged in activities like hospitals, schools, mobile dispensaries and so on. The Kanchi seer, Swaminarayan, Amritanandmayi and Swadhyaya Pariwar are just a few names and if there are wrong deeds they are opposed and exposed without any mercy by Hindus themselves, while other religious faithfuls try to hide it under the cover of secularism.
A swami like Sai Baba has contributed most to establish the technical and medical colleges and provided drinking water facility to Ananthpur district. Similarly Mata Amritanandmayi is hailed as a reformist Hindu seer, building super speciality hospitals and educational institutions. Ramakrishna Mission revolutionised the whole concept of a sanyasi through the principle of “Jiber Shewa Shiver Shewa”, that is, to serve humanity is to serve God.
It will be a sad day if driven to the wall Hindus start organising themselves on the lines of a church or an Islamic ummah to be heard and recognised. That would be the Islamisation process, as brutal and proselytising in its character as it could be.
In any event, and to return to the case of the Sankaracharya, Hindus will feel both shame and anger in either situation – the seer’s conviction or release – and this could erupt at a time no one can predict. Hindus should adopt a policy of wait and watch and hope that this case is transferred out of Tamil Nadu, as the state has become a den of revenge and hate.
If the courts hold he is guilty, there ought to be no complaints. If he is innocent, let the law say so and till then let him pass through the most excruciatingly grilling time. We have passed through more traumatic times. On the contrary the shock may bring some change in our lethargic attitudes towards dharma and its exponents.
Mercifully no power is a permanent one, even Saddam had to quit. But the State, especially one that prides itself on its secularism, ought to have used more caution and discretion.
(The author is Editor, Panchjanya, the RSS news magazine.)

0 Comments:
Post a Comment
<< Home